Our Klamath Basin Water Crisis
Upholding rural Americans' rights to grow food,
own property, and caretake our wildlife and natural resources.
Simpson's salmon recovery, dam breaching plan a 'nonstarter,' ag reps sayby MATTHEW WEAVER Capital Press 2/9/21
U.S. Rep. Mike Simpson says his plan to end all salmon litigation and remove four Snake River dams would offer agriculture unprecedented legal protection, but industry stakeholders say it’s a nonstarter.
Simpson, R-Idaho, has not proposed legislation, but on Feb. 7 released a $33.5 billion concept for salmon recovery, which includes removing the Lower Granite, Little Goose, Lower Monumental and Ice Harbor dams on the lower Snake River in 2030 and 2031.
“It’s such a different approach,” said a Simpson representative, speaking on on background. “We’re not saying, ‘Take the dams out and save salmon.’ We’re saying, ‘Save agriculture, replace everything and then save salmon.’”
If the dams are removed, each interest group would need sufficient resources to replace the benefits they currently receive, the representative said.
Replacement power generation would have to be built and online by 2030, prior to breaching the dams.
The concept includes an automatic 35-year extension of licensing for all remaining public and private dams generating more than 5 megawatts in the Columbia River Basin. This would “lock in” the dams and eliminate the “slippery slope” argument of, “If you allow them to remove these four dams they will go after the other main-stem Columbia River dams and others,” the representative said.
Under the concept, if the dams are removed, any litigation related to anadromous fish within the Columbia River system under the Endangered Species Act, National Environmental Policy Act or the Clean Water Act would be immediately halted and stayed for 35 years.
The plan combines many different elements that are not necessarily related, including fish recovery, energy generation and electricity rates, said Kristin Meira, executive director of the Pacific Northwest Waterways Association.
Each element requires its own intense inquiry and study, she said.
“Unfortunately, the idea of Snake River dam breaching is a non-starter when it comes for how we move cargo and ultimately for our energy portfolio,” she said. Taking out the dams would make that stretch of the Snake River impassable for barge traffic.
Stakeholders also say breaching the dams won’t achieve salmon recovery, pointing to fish declines along the West Coast due to ocean temperatures, runoff and other factors.
Four of 13 endangered salmon populations listed traverse the Snake River dams, said Glen Squires, CEO of the Washington Grain Commission.
“Everybody knows salmon are not doing well regardless of the rivers that have dams, don’t have dams,” Squires said.
Removal of the dams and the navigation system would affect reliability and timeliness of of wheat delivery to customers overseas, Squires said.
“When we visit with overseas buyers, very seldom, if ever, do they ask about what’s going on with the barge system,” he said. “What they ask about is, what’s going on with the rail system?”
Transportation costs to get wheat to West Coast ports would increase by 50% to 100%, said Michelle Hennings, Washington Association of Wheat Growers executive director.
Barging is the most carbon-friendly mode of transportation, Hennings said. Switching to trucks and trains would likely increase carbon dioxide and other harmful emissions by over 1.25 million tons per year.
“This is not a plan that gets us on a greener path when it comes to cargo movement,” Meira said.
“That’s for them to figure out, the environmental groups,” the representative of Simpson’s office said. “They’re apparently more concerned about the salmon going endangered because of the dams than emissions.”
Hennings said Simpson’s concept is a “huge worry.” The $33.5 billion figure “won’t even begin to cover what it would take to redo our whole transportation mode and clean up the impacts it would have on everything, including agriculture,” she said.
Simpson believes Pacific Northwest members of Congress are in a unique position to include the effort under President Joe Biden’s $2 trillion to $3 trillion national clean energy stimulus bill, expected to be proposed later this year. Simpson’s concept would represent 1% to 2% of the total package.
“Mike’s trying to end the salmon wars for all agriculture, not just those four dams,” the representative said. “We could catch lightning in a bottle here and reset agriculture, energy and bring back salmon for the next 50 to 70 years. We can control our destiny instead of letting a judge figure it out for us, or some other Congress down the road.”
Northwest and national wheat organizations will reach out to Simpson’s office, Hennings said.
“Targeted mitigation funds to attempt to address local impacts miss the point that these industries are part of something so much larger,” Meira said.
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, any copyrighted material herein is distributed without profit or payment to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit research and educational purposes only. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml
Page Updated: Thursday February 18, 2021 03:18 PM Pacific
Copyright © klamathbasincrisis.org, 2001 - 2021, All Rights Reserved